As of this month, a truck collects one kind of Harvard household waste at the end of the driveway. Black Earth Compost's curbside food-scrap pickup was scheduled to start in town on November 12, according to the Harvard Climate Initiative, and 45 households had signed up a week before launch. Everything else still goes to Depot Road on Wednesday mornings or Saturdays, in green bags and three separate recycling streams.
The timing matters. The town is also deciding how the Transfer Station will keep running while the old landfill under it is capped, and townwide curbside trash collection is one of the options on the table. The compost bin comes into that discussion as an add-on to the dump run. The town's own former Transfer Station committee proposed the same partnership as a way to make the station better.
What the Dump Run Costs Now, and Where Compost Fits
Harvard pays for trash by the bag. The FY2027 Transfer Station sticker covers July 1, 2026 through June 30, 2027. The Harvard Press reported that it costs $140, or $130 for residents over 60. Green bags come in packs of five, with prices listed in the town's July 2026 notice. A cash-only machine at Hildreth House, 15 Elm Street, sells bags and punch cards.
Black Earth's Harvard service runs on a different schedule and is priced differently.
| Transfer Station, Depot Road | Black Earth curbside compost | |
|---|---|---|
| Access | FY2027 sticker, $140 or $130 for residents over 60 | Subscription through Black Earth |
| Per-use cost | 5 x 15-gallon bags for $10; 5 x 33-gallon bags for $20 | $94.99 for six months |
| Schedule | Wednesday 7:30 to 11:30 a.m.; Saturday 8 a.m. to 2 p.m. | Every other week, bin at the curb by 6 a.m. |
| What it takes | Trash, three-stream recycling, hard-to-handle items | Food scraps, including meat, bones, dairy and certified-compostable tableware |
| Extras | Take-It-Or-Leave-It reuse shed | Starter bin and liners; spring voucher for a cubic-foot bag of compost |
Here is a simple way to compare. Six months of every-other-week pickup comes to about 13 collections, or roughly $7.30 each. The full $94.99 is about what 24 of the large 33-gallon green bags would cost. In a pay-per-bag town, the compost bin is priced like the trash it keeps out of the green bag.
That matters because the bag system already changes how people throw things away. Libby Levison, a former member of two Transfer Station committees, wrote in a Harvard Press "Consider This" column that, according to former DPW Director Tim Kilhart, solid waste leaving the station fell 47% from 2019 through December 2023. According to a MassDEP fact sheet, food waste is more than 23% of all trash in Massachusetts, and homes and municipalities produce about 46% of the state's food waste. For Harvard, that is the part of the bag the green-bag fee has never been able to reach.
Three Years of Committee Work Before the First Pickup
The service took a while to arrive. The Harvard Press reported that the Harvard Climate Initiative Committee first contacted Black Earth in late 2022, through former member Lucy Wallace. The effort stalled after early outreach drew little interest, including a low turnout at the November 2024 Pumpkin Smash. It started again when Nancy Hartshorne joined the committee. She worked with Deborah O'Rourke, other committee members and Town Administrator Dawn Dunbar.
Hartshorne moved to town in 2021. She told the Press that signing up for Black Earth's residential waitlist was "one of the very first things I did," and that her sign-up "just sat there, it didn't go anywhere."
Black Earth started in Gloucester in 2011. It already serves Acton, Ayer, Groton, Littleton, Maynard and Stow, and about 115 cities and towns in all. Harvard was surrounded by towns with the service before it had the service itself. Jon Laurie, Black Earth's municipal coordinator, explained the case for it in terms of trucking costs in an interview with the Harvard Press:
"Massachusetts has the most expensive trash trip fees in the country. We actually ship an enormous amount of waste out of state, which costs even more money, but that is where the landfill space is."
The company describes the curbside service as a complement to backyard bins. Most backyard piles don't get hot enough to break down dairy, fats, oils, larger amounts of cooked food, or compostable take-out containers. The full list is in Black Earth's what's compostable guide. It goes well past kitchen scraps to include lobster shells, natural wood ash, pet hair and the Halloween pumpkin, as long as the candle is out. Sign-up is through the Harvard page on Black Earth's site, which the town also linked in its October 26 notice.
Why the Committee Wanted Black Earth at Depot Road
The 2023-2024 Transfer Station Committee visited three nearby transfer stations, held forums, analyzed FY2023 revenue and expenses, and surveyed more than 340 residents. Two of its recommendations were a contract and a partnership with Black Earth Compost to divert organics from the waste stream. The committee saw composting as one more drop-off at the station. Curbside pickup is a different route to the same goal.
Levison's column also lists what the station handles that a curbside hauler might not:
- Batteries, fluorescent bulbs, scrap metal, fireplace ash, electronics, mattresses, appliances, antifreeze and waste oil
- Three-stream recycling, which keeps paper dry and glass out of the cardboard
- Per-bag pricing, so smaller households pay for what they actually throw away
- No extra charge for driveways on a curve or slope, which newer automated trucks charge more for, and no access problem for private roads that hauler trucks can't use
The committee's list also included longer Wednesday hours until 1:30 p.m. for lunchtime drop-offs, a larger Take-It-Or-Leave-It shed, and an April-to-June sticker for spring home buyers. The column is one former member's view. The question it argues over is now with the Select Board.
The Landfill Under the Station
The Transfer Station and the DPW both sit on Harvard's former Depot Road landfill. According to Harvard Press reporting based on MassDEP records, the site took waste from as early as the 1940s until fall 1984. The town built the Transfer Station in 1983 and 1984 to replace it. MassDEP wrote to the town in February 2022 asking about the site's monitoring and inspection history. The town had hired the engineering firm Tighe & Bond for an initial site assessment by early 2023. The landfill now has to be formally capped under state oversight.
On September 1, Dunbar presented the Select Board with five siting concepts. Her preferred one, Option D, rebuilds the DPW roughly on its current footprint and keeps all three Depot Road athletic fields. The Transfer Station would shift temporarily while the landfill is capped in stages, then move back. The Harvard Press reported that keeping the Transfer Station, as opposed to switching to townwide trash collection, remained a priority for Dunbar. DPW Director Eric Ryder said the extent of the cap on the roughly four-acre footprint will depend on state requirements.
The October 5 public forum presentation lists every option the town has studied for the station: townwide curbside collection, regionalizing with other towns, private haulers, relocating within the current site, or keeping the station open only as a Center for Hard to Recycle Materials. The same presentation sets out the next steps:
- The Select Board makes a final siting decision based on public feedback.
- The Permanent Building Committee is brought in, and the town hires an Owner's Project Manager.
- A design engineer is hired and design work happens over the winter.
- The project goes out to bid in March.
- Town Meeting votes on construction funding in late April or early May 2027, followed by a ballot question in May.
Taken together, Harvard spends this winter on design while the first compost bins go out at the curb. The town meets the station question again at spring Town Meeting.
Reuse Already Has a Home in Town
The station's Take-It-Or-Leave-It shed is a free reuse area for clean, usable things like books, sports equipment, small furniture, housewares, medical equipment and toys. The Harvard Climate Initiative Committee's newer project fixes things instead of passing them on. Repair Cafe Harvard met November 14 at the Harvard Senior Center, 16 Lancaster County Road, offering free help with small electrical appliances, clothing, furniture, toys and wireless items. The town's news flash page is where Repair Cafe dates are posted.
The same committee is behind both the repair table and the compost bin. Both fit the per-bag system Harvard already uses, because every repaired toaster and every bin of scraps means less trash going into a paid green bag.
Peggy has watched Harvard work through questions like this for more than three decades. If you'd like to talk through what the Depot Road plans could mean for your part of Harvard, Peggy Dowcett is happy to have that conversation. Work With Peggy.